Other

Thumbs down for the Up System

OtherApr 28, 2015

Thumbs down for the Up System

Columnist Peter Smith explains why he thinks the Up System, which dictates that a store’s sales staff take turns approaching customers, is inane.

Peter-Smith-article.jpg
Peter Smith, author of “Hiring Squirrels: 12 Essential Interview Questions to Uncover Great Retail Sales Talent,” has spent 30 years building retail sales teams and has worked in wholesale as well. Reach him at Dublinsmith@yahoo.com.

One of my pet peeves in retail is the Up System. It is one of the most inane of dictates on a sales floor and it is responsible for more lost business than we can ever know.

It is hard to argue that the basic premise of the Up System is wrong; it presumes that all salespeople are created equally and, as such, they ought to have exactly the same number of opportunities to engage and close prospects. To that extent, every salesperson is expected to take turns approaching customers so that each of them has an equal number of opportunities to be successful.

If we lived in a world where all salespeople were created equally the Up System would be a very nice way to ensure equity and harmony on the sales floor. We might even choose an appropriate musical score as a backdrop to this scene of wonderment and bliss, with happily fulfilled customers, served by delightfully pleasant and incredibly effective salespeople. Do you remember when we had record players? This is where the needle scratches across the vinyl, making a truly awful sound and bringing this fairy tale vignette to a screeching halt.

Alas, the world does not work that way. All salespeople are not created equal. Each interaction with a prospect affords your business a great opportunity to turn each prospect into a satisfied customer and the Up System will ensure neither a harmonious work environment nor a profitable or rewarding experience for any of the parties involved: you, your employees or, most importantly, your customers.

The net effect of the Up System is that your best salespeople will have less opportunity to do what they do best as they take a backseat to far less capable salespeople. Your customers will, all too often, be denied the best opportunity to satisfy their needs and your store will be infinitely less successful, and less profitable, than it otherwise should be.

The best argument for the Up System is that you want to:
-- Give everyone the same opportunity to be successful;
-- That you do not want to exacerbate the disparity that might already exist between your top-performers and your under-performers; and
-- That you do not want to create a culture so competitive that it negatively impacts the customer experience.

Let’s address the two main arguments cited above: 1) the basic premise

of fairness and 2) the customer experience.

In the first instance, you will find that there is, and will likely always be, a markedly different level of performance between your better salespeople and your weaker salespeople. Those folks who are wired to sell will, with very few exceptions, always be at the top of the performance pyramid. Conversely, the salespeople who are generally amongst your lowest performers, on the whole, will always be your lowest performers.

Your best salespeople do a better job converting prospects into customers. Those customers typically spend more per transaction than customers converted by your least successful salespeople, and they are also more inclined to add-on to their purchases and to lay the foundation for future purchases. Ensuring that ineffective salespeople have equal opportunity to satisfy customers is tantamount to charting a course to lose business.

There are all sorts of theories as to why a person walks into your store; retail therapy, killing time, scouting work for some possible future purchase, etc.

Here’s a thought, and it is the basic premise that ought to drive your culture, your hiring, your compensation plan and your training: a prospect always visits your store with the intention of buying something. I cannot be any more direct than that.

I know that everyone will not make a purchase every time he or she visits a store. What I am saying, as emphatically as possible, is that to be successful we always presume that the customer will always consider making a purchase.

We must also communicate, consistently and with emphasis, that this premise must shape the attitude and mindset of all our salespeople. All customers who come into our store do so with the intention of buying something, period. End of story. The facts will, of course, prove otherwise but that attitude must govern our approach and our expectations.

As to the third point, that you don’t want to create an overly competitive culture, Dixon wrote in The Effortless Experience, “Customers really don’t care to be delighted by you as much as they want to just get on with their lives, so your job is to eliminate the obstacles that prevent your customer from being able to do just that.”

If you believe that your customer’s main purpose in visiting your store is to have their needs satisfied by a confident and efficient sales professional than you owe them the very best opportunity to do just that. And that, in my experience, has always been and will always be best served by exposing them as much as possible to your best salespeople. Your business and your customers deserve no less.

Peter Smith, author of Hiring Squirrels: 12 Essential Interview Questions to Uncover Great Retail Sales Talent, has spent 30 years building sales teams at retail and working with independent retailers to offer counsel and advice on matters of sales, marketing, personnel, training and compensation. He has worked in retail and on the wholesale end of the business with companies such as Tiffany & Co. and Hearts On Fire. Smith can be reached at Dublinsmith@yahoo.com and on LinkedIn.

Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

trend retail.jpg
PodcastsJan 12, 2026
The latest poscast

test

Screenshot from 2026-01-12 06-22-03.png
PodcastsJan 12, 2026
New podcast without sponsor

test

20210205_Alexia_Connellan_Gatsby_earrings.jpg
TrendsJan 12, 2026
New test Article

test article

trend ss21@2x.jpg
Brought to you by
new sponsored article

test

2019_De_Beers_rough_NEW_1.jpg
PodcastsJan 12, 2026
New sponsored podcast

test

Weekly QuizOct 03, 2024
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
MNQ FINAL - NJ web - 1872 x 1052 px.png
PodcastsJan 12, 2026
Introducing My Next Question, the Podcast

A monthly podcast series for jewelry professionals

Screenshot from 2025-12-31 12-03-28.png
PodcastsDec 31, 2025
Test new podcast post

Test new podcast post

Jewelers Mutual Group Cybersecurity
Brought to you by
Navigating Cybersecurity: Essential Guidance for Jewelers

From protecting customer data to safeguarding inventory records, it's crucial to learn how to tackle cybersecurity challenges.

MNQ - studio - screen -1920 x 1080.png
PodcastsDec 29, 2025
Molly Test Podcast Episode

This is the abstract for Molly Test Podcast Episode

image 169 (4 col).png
PodcastsDec 10, 2025
Podcast With Video

Podcast Without Video or Audio or Image

image 169 (4 col).jpg
Recorded WebinarsDec 04, 2025
New Recorded Webinar for tests

New Recorded Webinar for tests

User-Avatar-PNG-Picture.png
PodcastsDec 03, 2025
Test Article Title

test Abstract

20210204_Couture_show_shot.jpg
PodcastsDec 02, 2025
New podcast

test desc

Screenshot from 2025-12-05 13-54-41.png
PodcastsNov 27, 2025
Test Podcast With Video

Test Podcast With Video. New interview with Ada Lovelace.

Image for tests
PodcastsNov 25, 2025
Test New Podcast Post

Abstract for tests. New Podcast interview with John Lennon, Jimi Hendrix and Jim Morison.

National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
ColumnistsOct 09, 2024
Peter Smith: 7 Things to Know When Selling Luxury

Ahead of the holiday season, Smith delves into the often subconscious reasons people buy luxury products for themselves or their loved ones.

Edgar Mitchell wearing Rolex watch on Apollo 14
AuctionsOct 09, 2024
Rolex Worn on Apollo 14 Mission Up for Sale

The GMT-Master “Pepsi” belonging to astronaut Edgar Mitchell is a standout in RR Auction’s online “Space Auction,” going on now.

Simon meet me at the mall campaign
MajorsOct 09, 2024
New Simon Campaign Invites Gen Z to ‘Meet Me At The Mall’

The ads celebrate the mall culture of the ‘80s and ‘90s.

Platinum Guild International training
MajorsOct 09, 2024
PGI Launches New Virtual Sales Training

Retail sales associates can access the video series on mobile to refresh their selling skills.

Gathering at Bharat Diamond Bourse for COVID vaccinations
Policies & IssuesOct 09, 2024
GJNRF: Reaching Out, Rebuilding Futures

For 25 years, India’s Gem & Jewellery National Relief Foundation has provided aid in the wake of war, natural disasters, and global crises.

Sotheby’s A Tsar’s Treasure: Ferdinand of Bulgaria
AuctionsOct 08, 2024
Sotheby’s Selling Jewelry That Belonged to a Bulgarian Tsar

The November auction will feature a collection of jewels owned by Ferdinand I, the first king of modern Bulgaria, and his family.

Rough diamonds mined at the Diavik Diamond Mine
SourcingOct 08, 2024
Rio Tinto Begins New Phase of Production That Will Extend Diavik’s Life

Commercial production has begun underground at the Canadian diamond mine’s A21 pipe.

Stock image of hand holding phone by keyboard
SurveysOct 08, 2024
What to Know About Online Shopping This Holiday Season

Deloitte and Adobe Analytics shared their insights on the season, from the retail sales forecast to the role of generative AI.

Sylvie and Uncommon Man Campaign
CollectionsOct 08, 2024
Sylvie Adds New Men’s Bands

The Texas-based jeweler collaborated with luxury clothing brand Uncommon Man on men’s bands designed with European influences.

Diamond on polishing wheel Venus Jewel India
SourcingOct 08, 2024
Is Current Diamond Industry Turbulence Shaping a ‘New Normal’?

Industry players have found ways to cope with market conditions while working to reshape themselves in the face of emerging realities.

Rio Tinto 2024 Beyond RareTM Tender Art Series
SourcingOct 07, 2024
Rio Tinto to Offer 76 Diamonds in 2024 Beyond Rare Tender

The sales event, in its second year, features a selection of rare diamonds from the miner’s Argyle and Diavik diamond mines.

Kristi Yamaguchi and Scott Heller
CollectionsOct 07, 2024
Olympian Kristi Yamaguchi Partners With Heller Jewelers on New Collection

A portion of the proceeds from the “Always Dream” collection will go to Yamaguchi's foundation, supporting early childhood literacy.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy